404 Page Design That Keeps Visitors on Your Website
A roofing client came to us in March because his phone had gone quiet. The site looked fine, the forms worked, and his ads were running.

A roofing client came to us in March because his phone had gone quiet. The site looked fine, the forms worked, and his ads were running. What nobody had checked was that a redesign eight months earlier had moved every service page from one URL pattern to another, and the printed magnets on about 400 customer fridges pointed at the old ones. Search Console was reporting 1,340 not found hits a month. Each of those people landed on a page that said "Oops! Page not found" in grey text, with no menu, no phone number and no way forward.
I spent two years drawing menus and fail states for small studios before I came to this agency, and the thing that strikes me about most small business 404 pages is how little thought goes into them compared to how much thought goes into a death screen in even a modest indie game. A game knows that the player failing is a normal part of play. A website treats a visitor hitting a dead URL as an embarrassment to be apologised for and then abandoned.
What a death screen gets right
In a well made game, the moment you fail you are given three things within half a second: a plain statement of what happened, the fastest possible route back into play, and a sense that the game still knows who you are. Celeste puts you back at the start of the screen almost instantly. Hades turns the failure into a room with choices in it. Even the bluntest version, the two words Dark Souls puts on the screen, is followed immediately by a loading screen that returns you to a bonfire you already know.
What none of them do is leave you looking at an apology. The player is not asked to feel bad, and they are certainly not asked to work out their own way back. Compare that with a 404 page carrying a cartoon and the words "we could not find what you were looking for", which states the problem and then stops.
The useful translation is not the visual style. It is the structure: say what happened in one short line, then give the visitor the two or three routes that cover most intentions, and keep the site's normal navigation visible so they are still somewhere rather than nowhere.
What a 404 page should actually contain
Here is the specification I now hand to every build, in order of how much it matters for a small business site.
| Element | Why it earns the space |
|---|---|
| Full site header and navigation | The single biggest fix. A visitor with the menu can rescue themselves |
| Phone number as a tap to call link | On a trades or service site this recovers the lead directly, with no further clicks |
| One sentence saying the page has moved or no longer exists | Plain language beats a joke. No error codes in the body copy |
| Three to five links to the pages people actually want | Your main services, contact, and the page the old URL most resembled |
| A search box, if your site has search | Useful on a site with more than about 30 pages, pointless on a 6 page site |
| The real HTTP 404 status in the response | A page that looks like a 404 but returns 200 pollutes your index for months |
That last row is the one that gets missed on hand built sites and on a surprising number of page builders. If the server returns a success status while showing error content, search engines treat it as a thin duplicate page and you end up with dozens of near identical URLs in the index. Check it with your browser's network panel: load a URL you know is wrong and look at the status on the document request. It should say 404.
The phone number row deserves a word too, because this is where a small business 404 differs completely from a large one. On a plumbing or roofing site, someone who typed a URL off a van or a magnet is the warmest visitor you will get that day. Our note on why your phone number belongs outside the mobile menu applies here with even more force, since a 404 page is where a hidden number costs you a booked job.
The advice I would push back on
Design blogs love a creative 404 page. The genre is well established: a lost astronaut, a cat knocking something off a table, a tiny game you can play, a 500 word riff on being lost. I have built two of those and I would not build another for a small business.
The problem is not that humour is wrong. It is that a joke takes up the position of highest attention on the page and then does not convert. A visitor who hits a dead URL on a roofing site is mid task, often on a phone, often in a hurry, and the measurable outcome is whether they reach a service page or the phone. On the roofing site we rebuilt, the new 404 page has no illustration at all, one line of text, the normal header, a tap to call button and four service links. In the four months after launch, 61 percent of the sessions that hit it continued to another page. The old one, cartoon included, had been losing nearly everyone.
Where a distinctive 404 does pay off is on a studio, portfolio or personality led site, where the page is part of the voice and the visitor is browsing rather than buying. Know which kind of site you are. Most of our clients are the first kind and think they are the second.
Where the hits actually come from
Before designing the page, spend twenty minutes finding out why people are reaching it. In almost every audit I have run, the sources sort into four groups of very different sizes.
Old URLs from a redesign are usually the largest group by a wide margin, and they are the ones you should fix with redirects rather than with a nicer error page. Map every old path to its closest live equivalent and set a 301. A spreadsheet with two columns, old and new, is the entire deliverable, and for a 30 page site it takes an afternoon.
Second, printed and physical sources: vehicle lettering, flyers, business cards, a QR code on a window sticker. These cannot be changed once they are out, so the URL on them must be redirected forever. I keep a short list of those paths in the project notes and flag them as permanent, because the next developer will otherwise clean them up in two years and break a van.
Third, mistyped and truncated URLs, which you can do little about beyond having a sane 404. Fourth, bots and scanners probing for login paths on software you do not run. That last group is often the majority of raw 404 counts in a server log, which is why I work from Search Console and analytics rather than the log when deciding what to redirect.
Build it once, then check it twice a year
The page itself is an hour of work. Use your standard template, write one line of copy, add the links, and make sure the button wording says where it goes rather than "go back", which is the point of button copy that tells people what happens next.
Then put a calendar reminder for every six months to open the not found report, look at the top ten paths, and decide for each one: redirect it, or leave it. Leaving it is a legitimate choice for a page that genuinely no longer exists and has no equivalent. Redirecting everything to the home page is not, because a visitor who wanted a specific service page and arrives at a generic home page usually leaves. If the destination is not clearly related, the 404 page does a better job than a bad redirect.
One extra step worth doing this week if you have changed your site recently: type three of your own old URLs from memory and see what happens. I find something wrong about half the time. The rest of what we have written on this sits in the web design section.
FAQ
Does a 404 page hurt my search rankings?
The page itself does not. Losing the inbound links and history attached to an old URL does, which is why a redirect beats an error page whenever a close equivalent exists. A handful of genuine 404s on a site is normal and expected.
Should I use 410 instead of 404?
Only for pages you have deliberately removed and never want crawled again, such as an expired job listing or a discontinued product. It tells search engines the removal is permanent, so they stop checking sooner. For everything else, 404 is the right answer.
Can I redirect all my 404s to the home page?
You can, and I would not. It hides the problem from your reports, confuses visitors who wanted something specific, and search engines often treat it as a soft 404 anyway. Redirect to the closest real match or show the error page.
How do I find out which pages are 404ing?
Search Console's page indexing report lists not found URLs with the pages that link to them, which is the fastest route. Your analytics will show landing page hits on the 404 path if you have named it clearly. Both beat reading raw server logs for this purpose.
More in Web Design
Web Design
Sticky Header Design That Helps Instead of Hiding Content
A plumber's website we audited last month had a sticky header 132 pixels tall.
Web Design
Portfolio Page Design for Trades and Local Studios
A landscaper we worked with last year had 214 photos on his portfolio page.
Web Design
Website Font Size That Reads Well on Every Screen
Customers are pinching to zoom on your service page, older visitors call instead of reading your prices, and the text that...